I hadn't thought about the painter Fairfield Porter in years, and he would never have crossed my mind had Regina Hackett at the Seattle P-I not mentioned him in her fabulous blog recently. The story is complicated, and I hesitate to even bring it up, but...
This is how I remember it:
Florence, Italy. January 1, 1993. It is one of the coldest days on record in the city; snow is predicted for overnight, the first time that has happened in decades. A recently married young couple--artists from America--weave their way through the crowded, cobblestone streets. The artists are cold, tired, loaded down with bags seemingly filled with bricks, and disoriented from twenty-odd hours of travelling from their home in Seattle.
The two stop to ask directions to their pensione from a nice looking Italian couple chatting amicably in front of a coffee bar. The Italians react coyly, as if they don't understand the young couple's broken Italian. How fucking obnoxious! think the Americans, If you don't know where it is, just say so. Don't play this pathetic game! When they part, the coy Italian man says, "Je suis desolée , Monsieur. Vraiment," and does a classic, Parisian shrug. It turns out that the Italians were in fact French and really didn't understand a word the Americans had said.
Skip ahead three months. The young American couple (Julie and me if you haven't already guessed) have rented a flat and settled into a life of drawing, painting and visiting museums, art and architecture that we had until then only read about in art history books. We were lucky; I had recieved a small grant, and neither of us had been to Europe before, so we sold our car, closed our bank accounts and bought two one-way tickets to Italy. We would worry about careers later. We saw a chance; an entire year to study Art. The real deal. The Mecca of the figurative tradition--a version of which I was practicing on canvas at the time--and nothing but time to paint, study, eat, and drink...la bella vita!
Skip ahead another month to a bitterly cold Wednesday night, the night that I first met John T. Spike, art historian, critic and author of a forthcoming book on Fairfield Porter which would soon be hailed as the 'definitive text' on the subject. By this time Julie and I had become regulars at a student gathering held in the basement of Florence's St. James Episcopal Church; cheap pasta, free chianti, and usually a movie, slide show, or lecture. On the night we met, Mr. Spike had given a lecture at that gathering on the artist Fairfield Porter, and afterward he announced he would be curating an art exhibition in the basement of the church, The exhibition title; "Ars Gratia Artis: Art for Art's Sake". That was the beginning of the end.
Later that evening, after several glasses of free chianti, I gathered enough courage to walk over and introduce myself to the illustrious Mr. Spike. He asked me what kind of artist I was. I told him I was a painter. A figurative painter. Oil on canvas. Very interested in developing some ideas from the Bay Area school, and particularly in cannibalizing the work of Nathan Oliviera, Richard Diebenkorn, and David Park all of whom had monographs that I regularly referred to in my studio.
Mr. Spike laughed. He was no more drunk than I, no doubt, but nevertheless. A loud laugh. Beads of sweat formed on my brow. Mr. Spike; Harvard PhD., lecturer at Yale, Princeton, and god knows where else. Me; 24-year-old unknown artist. What did I know?
Mr. Spike said, "Does anybody paint anymore? You can't do that. Everyone is doing installations now. Or performance. Or video." He smiled at his giggling entourage. At this point I wasn't sure if he was mocking me--the quaint little painter--or trying to include me in a little ironic bravado--yes, of course you are a painter, why would you be making trendy, superficial installation art and living here in Florence?
I tried not to miss a beat, "Of course I, um, paint," I said, trying not to slur. "Painting is not dead, um, it's alive and, um, at least, um..." It was the best I could do.
But here is the irony of that encounter, and similar ones I had with Mr. Spike that year. Yes, it's true that I was exploring a kind of perversion of Bay Area figurative abstraction at the time, but I was also writing a thesis on the transformation of the socio-economic role of artists, from the beginning of the Renaissance to the end of it; from artisan/laborer to the epitome of the cult of personality. It is a transformation that still resonates today. And in truth, I was beginning to think that painting was out of touch, anachronistic, rife with nostalgia and burdened by the weight of history and NYC vitriolics, particularly in light of what was happening in film and the web at the time.
Mr. Spike--in fact a passionate defender of painting as it turned out, 20th Century American realism to be exact--only added to my suspicions about my painting practice. Like his subject Fairfield Porter, Mr. Spike seemed hopelessly lost to nostalgia, a romantic living in a dream of his own making; a dandy--irrelevant, spoiled and out of touch. Eventually, I found it difficult to separate Spike, Porter, and figurative painting. I began to view my practice--with no little help from Arnold Hauser's classic text "The Social History of Art" among others--as an extension of the Porter/Spike/Painting triumverate. In short, I thought my painting was...irrelevant.
I cut the stretcher bars from my works in progress, rolled up the six linen canvases--and never looked at them again (a la Baldessari, Park, and countless other artists given to fits of melodrama).
Jump ahead 14 years to today, February 16, 2007. It is a drizzly Friday afternoon here in Seattle. I should be in my studio working on my new series of pictures, a kind of collision of architectural paradigms; Koenig meets Mary Colter, as I joked to John Jahn over at PORT.
Will I work with paint today? Maybe.
Much has happened since those bucolic days in Florence. Painting has not died, obviously, nor has it faded in importance. It made it through it's 'crisis of legitimacy' and has, in fact, proven itself more relevant than ever as the world becomes more and more inundated with moving images; film, television, and most recently, broadband internet. Painting has survived Mike Kelly and Martin Kippenberger, Brice Marden and Stephen Prina, Peter Halley, Jeff Koons, Marcel Broodthaers, Ross Bleckner, Rudolph Stingel, Peyton, Owens, Freud, Hirst, Shaw, Currin, Murakami...
Painting today is crowded with vital, dedicated and serious exploration, so I will end this post with a few quotes I found written down in my notebooks. And then maybe I'll pick up a brush. Anything is possible...
"If some painting is still to come, if painters are still to come, they will not come from where we expect them to." --Yve-Alain Bois in "Painting: The Task of Mourning"
"Today, there is an almost uncanny resemblance between the discourses around the status of contemporary painting and rock music. The techno-factions in both art and music have repeatedly buried the canvas and the guitar for good, and time and again both have risen from the grave, claiming that their time had not yet come, that there was still something substantial to say with and about them."--Jorg Heiser in “The Odd Couple”
"These paintings are reconceived in terms of the larger cultural spectacle without allegory, or any idea that looks backwards for its own relevance. I want them to be the symbolic language object come-to-life, the way it is impossible to ignore something that stirs in the ashes, not dead, but rising from the death of everything that has been poisoned and made extinct around it." --Daniel Mendel-Black in "The Paintings Are Alive Manifesto"
"Yes, I am the first to admit that my paintings are willful perversions of my training...Inversion and perversion only serve to reinscribe the law they seek to undermine...It is all shit. The law is there. And in my last breath, like all lapsed believers, I will whimper and ask for forgiveness. I will die groveling, begging to be reinstated into the ranks I never truly left: the ranks of the law-abiding. Stupid me.I was a beliver all along." --Mike Kelly in "Goin' Home, Goin' Home"
-Daniel